REVIEW: Comedic suspense and more drives Central Square Theater’s ‘The Mystery of Irma Vep: A Penny Dreadful’
Mummies and vampires and werewolves – oh my!
However, as Paul Melendy as Nicodemus quips, “Don’t be skeered.”
Offering much more absurdity and laughter than horror or gore, The Mystery of Irma Vep leans on comedic suspense in 1930s Mandacrest Manor. Seeing a Penny Dreadful for the first time with some hesitancy, I’ll take it.
With striking direction and transformative set design by David R. Gammons, Central Square Theater concludes their season with Charles Ludlam’s gothic satire The Mystery of Irma Vep: A Penny Dreadful continuing live and in person at Central Square Theater in Cambridge, Massachusetts extended through Sunday, June 21. This two hander adult production displays valuable captions, contains nudity, the action is not limited to the stage and runs two hours including one intermission. If you are unaware of what a Penny Dreadful means, see here. Click here for more information and for tickets.

Taking cues from classic gothic romantic literature, The Mystery of Irma Vep: A Penny Dreadful focuses on the highly anticipated appearance of Paul Melendy as new mistress of Mandacrest Manor Lady Enid Hilcrest, the new wife of Gabriel Graetz as widower and Egyptologist Lord Edgar Hillcrest. However, does Lord Edgar’s late wife, Irma Vep, still haunt these eerie halls?

A gleaming and almost sterile looking white foyer in Mandacrest Manor by David R. Gammons is much more than it seems illuminated by Jeff Adelburg’s flashing, tense and vivid lighting which take on a variety of crude shapes and sizes scattered around the room with a glowing fireplace. Composer Nate Tucker skillfully exacts a carefully executed sound design and special effects crucial in this twisted vintage gothic Victorian mystery. Costumer Seth Bodie creates eccentric, vintage, outrageous and vibrant ensembles varying from grand robes with gold trim to 30s three piece suits to revealing negligees.

In a production that can be less than subtle, striking the right tone is paramount and this duo certainly has a way with words and sharp comedic timing in every over the top scenario which includes stuffed animals, a picnic table cloth and a tree stump. Gabriel Graetz and Paul Melendy work remarkably well off each other in every incredulous expression, wild accent, or improvisational and self aware moment. They also take a lot of complicated cues from each other even during the production’s most awkward scenarios in this vintage melodrama while inviting the audience in on its campy humor and its occasionally moving moments.

Melendy steps into each melodramatic character distinctly, but boasting scratchy vocals, a meandering gate and a slovenly appearance, Melendy’s Nicodemus may be my favorite character and one that is not to be underestimated. The mysterious groundskeeper is protective and shrewd as he lurks about the manor. Melendy as naïve and vampy chorus girl Lady Enid Hilcrest is self conscious under the suspicion of Graetz as stern and traditional housekeeper Jane who also portrays Lord Edgar Hillcrest…and you get the idea. Depicting an actor reacting to portraying multiple characters is no easy feat, but both do so seamlessly. Special accolades to the costume and stage hands for those glorious lightning fast costume and prop changes!

Not a fan of the superfluous nudity even if it was for bizarre comedic purposes, but this production is funny and two great actors performing this campy gothic mystery made me laugh anyway.
Central Square Theater concludes their season with Charles Ludlam’s gothic satire The Mystery of Irma Vep: A Penny Dreadful continuing live and in person at Central Square Theater in Cambridge, Massachusetts extended through Sunday, June 28. If you enjoy the soundtrack to this production, it is available on Spotify. Click here for more information and for tickets.





















































