The Sleepless Critic

REVIEW: Fandom takes an all-consuming turn in Samantha Hurley’s dark comedy ‘I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire’

Posted on 1 Day Ago by The Sleepless Critic

This is not your average teenage crush.

A wild-eyed teenager is determined to make her dreams come true…even if he is under duress.

With zany direction by Sydney T. Grant, Yorick Ensemble continues Samantha Hurley’s dark comedy, ‘I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire’ live and in person through Saturday, September 13 at Hovey Players in the D’Angio Building in Waltham, Massachusetts. This semi-interactive fringe production is not limited to the stage, contains some mature language and humor and runs approximately two hours with an intermission. Click here for more information and for tickets.

Demi DiCarlo in Yorick Ensemble’s ‘I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire’

Set in 2004 in secluded South Dakota, I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire infuses online fandom and Y2K pop hits into a dark coming-of-age comedy with hints of Misery for beginners and a whisper of Carrie. However without the gore, not quite a horror movie and never really takes itself too seriously.

Alexa Erb’s illustrative scenic and props design produces a brightly colored bedroom with traces of Shelby’s various obsessions including a princess petal bed canapé, flowered walls covered in Tobey Maguire photos, gleeful frog printed bed sheets, Barbie dolls and a curious chart of Tobey’s whereabouts. Josh Telepman keeps up the show’s seemingly cheerful façade in jungle prints, fanciful pink layered ensembles with lace gloves and a fanciful wedding dress.

Crossing a soft smile with a seemingly vacant stare, Demi DiCarlo impresses and is occasionally sympathetic as intense Shelby who may be calculating but not diabolical, at least according to her trusty issue of Cosmopolitan Magazine. She quips, “I’m not bad. I’m romantic.” However, her anxious smile, madcap reactions and unsettling actions hint at something more just underneath the surface.

Demi DiCarlo in Yorick Ensemble’s ‘I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire’ Photo by Josh Telepman

Socially awkward and an only child, Shelby spends her days after school in a basement bedroom as President and founder of the Tobey Maguire Fan Club communicating to members through a handheld camera disassociating and fantasizing about actor Tobey Maguire. Secluded from the rest of the house, her basement bedroom almost seems like she was sent there to be ignored except when her nagging mother needs something.

Learning the facts of life through Cosmo, fairy tales and all things Tobey Maguire, delusional Shelby has deduced that the only solution to her isolation and loneliness is to capture and marry Tobey Maguire at the ripe age of 14.

To make matters more absurd, teenage Shelby does (seemingly impossibly) capture Tobey Maguire and has him chained in the basement. Where is security or his entourage? It is also hard to imagine Tobey Maguire afraid of a 14 year old, but the Tobey in front of her is not the Tobey she imagines. Sam Hackett is quite fittingly not a Tobey Maguire doppelganger portraying far from that sparkling example of optimism and well meaning persona amplified in Spiderman’s No Way Home. Never meet your heroes, right?

Alison Butts and Demi DiCarlo in Yorick Ensemble’s ‘I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire’ Photo by Josh Telepman

As Shelby’s illusions shatter, things really start to get out of hand.

Alison Butts does double time portraying various roles that move the plot along from the voice of Shelby’s mom to a kooky real estate agent.

With flashes of Y2K nostalgia, I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire has its moments of intriguing self-aware humor, a wealth of pop culture references and a special appearance which will not be revealed here. It would do better without its share of superfluous and raunchy gags that do not advance the plot and would benefit spending more time fleshing out what makes Hackett’s egotistical, complaining, irascible and drug-addled Tobey tick.

Alison Butts in Yorick Ensemble’s ‘I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire’ Photo by Josh Telepman

I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire is a cautionary tale of obsession, loneliness, isolation, trauma and infamy which, like Shelby, loses itself a bit along the way. As someone who has loved something teetering beyond reason, this outlandish tale stretches the imagination to conceive a dark comedy of what happens when fantasy and reality collide.

Demi DiCarlo and Alison Butts in Yorick Ensemble’s ‘I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire’ Photo by Josh Telepman

Yorick Ensemble continues Samantha Hurley’s dark comedy, I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire live and in person through Saturday, September 12 at Hovey Players in the D’Angio Building in Waltham, Massachusetts. Click here for more information and for tickets.

REVIEW: The wild pursuit of love and meaning in Gloucester’s Stage’s world premiere of ‘Dalloway: First Love’

Posted on 16 Days Ago by The Sleepless Critic

Who knew a sprawling tree would hold such meaning?

In the far off 1890 English countryside, Clarissa, deep in thought, is anticipating her 18^th birthday cradled in a symbolic tree torn between coming of age and missing her late older sister. Like many literary heroines, she does not want to grow up or for her world to change as certain arrangements are being made behind the scenes as she longs to become a writer.

Fueled by Rebecca Bradshaw’s prognosticative direction, Gloucester Stage Company continues the world `premiere of Lindsay Joelle’s romantic dramedy, Dalloway: First Love live and in person at Gloucester Stage in Gloucester, Massachusetts through Saturday, August 29. Playwright Lindsay Joelle introduces this coming-of-age story-within-a-story production which runs approximately two hours with an intermission. Click here for more information and for tickets.

Gloucester Stage Company’s world premiere production of “Dalloway”, written by Lindsay Joelle and directed by Rebecca Bradshaw. The play stars Josephine Moshiri Elwood as Clarisa Parry, Haley Dyana Schwartz as Sally Seton, Shobhit Piasa as Peter Walsh, and Jesse Garlick as The Slew. The production runs August 13 to August 29 at the Natti-Willsky Performance Center, 267 East Main Street in Gloucester, MA.

© 2026 Shawn G. Henry • 978-590-4869

GSC-Dalloway-260812_013

Dalloway First Love stands as a prequel to Virginia Wolff’s famous novel, Mrs. Dalloway and is also a somewhat modern take on a period piece. I have not read Virginia Wolff’s work, but it does not seem necessary to read it in order to understand or appreciate this production.

With subtle winks to the future of women, Dalloway First Love has one foot inside the world of 1890 and the other exploring women’s contemporary accomplishments. As several suitors compete for Clarissa’s affections, Elwood’s Clarissa, while open to falling in love, dreams of a world with options. The famous English folk ballad, Scarborough Fair, also seems to also serve as a touchstone between classic and modern day interwoven into this period piece.

Enhanced by Aubrey Dube’s soothing sound design, Scenic designer Kristin Loeffler draws from a rural landscape as this large and symbolic tree stands as the production’s centerpiece occasionally surrounded by a Victrola, dangling chandelier, decanter and dining room set. Capitalized by Josephine Moshiri Elwood’s delicately detailed signature lilac gown, costumer Chelsea Kerl’s presents an elegant array of period pieces including puffy silhouette lace dresses as well as stately ties, button down coat and tails in velvet and pinstripes.

Bright eyed Josephine Moshiri Elwood is no stranger to period pieces having previously performed as vivacious Emma in Actors Shakespeare Company’s period play with a modern twist, Emma in 2024. Elwood is in her element and displays charismatic charm and a way with words as pensive Clarissa, especially in a laugh out loud moment when she passionately jokes about being ravaged by gravity. Daring, adventuresome, impressionable and somewhat naïve, Elwood’s Clarissa is an easy individual to root and become protective of as she shares her hopes and dreams apart from societal norms roaming her family’s Bourton estate.

While Elwood shares genuine and unrefined chemistry with Shobhit Piasa as Clarissa’s boastful yet well meaning childhood chum Peter who longs for something more, it is Haley Dyana Schwartz as enigmatic, manipulative, shrewd and persistent Sally who indulges her hopes and is consistently nearby with an agenda all her own. Schwartz is captivating as Sally who boasts a seemingly charismatic zest for life. However, Peter is not to be underestimated.

Jesse Garlick shows off his range and serves ample comic relief stepping into a few characters from egotistical and entitled to outlandish to humble and heroic as The Slew.

Funny and wistful, Dalloway First Love also explores several themes such as grief, status, ambition, growing up, prejudice and discovery. Though the production could be a bit tighter in its narrative, the production is at its best when it explores Clarissa’s profound introspectiveness discovering what will be her next step.

Gloucester Stage continues the world premiere of Lindsay Joelle’s romantic dramedy, Dalloway: First Love live and in person at Gloucester Stage in Gloucester, Massachusetts through Saturday, August 29. Click here for more information and for tickets.

REVIEW: ‘Traveling Shoes’ an uplifting and resonating journey of perseverance

Posted on 18 Days Ago by The Sleepless Critic

“Every song is someone’s story.”

This is just a sample of the insightfulness infused into Christian David’s melodious new musical revue workshop, Traveling Shoes. Featuring scattered testimonials, gospel history, mighty vocals and hopeful life lessons, Traveling Shoes demonstrates that traveling armed with faith and the Gospel brings joy and resilience amidst life’s sufferings.

Written and under Christian David’s direction and music direction and co-choreographed with sleek and interconnected choreography by both Christian David and Ramone Owens, C David Entertainment presented Traveling Shoes: A Revival of Sound, Soul and Story live and in person for free and for one night only on Sunday August 9 at 6PM at the Multicultural Arts Center in Cambridge, Massachusetts. This semi-interactive musical revue encourages the audience to clap, sing, stand, praise and respond to the music as they wish and ran 90 minutes with no intermission. This engaging show is also aiming for a Broadway run. Click here for more information and for future performances.

Christian David & Tiffany Binion in ‘Traveling Shoes’ Photo by Najee Brown

Having been to the Multicultural Arts Center before, this pristine setting with wooden doors and immaculate etchings already infuses regality into the production’s modestly staged set which includes chairs posing as pews with Bibles and a grand piano.

Doris Bumpus & Levetta Hall in ‘Traveling Shoes’ Photo by Najee Brown

Welcome to Holy Hail Baptist Church where pastors and church goers share their testimonies, suffering, joy and more importantly, community while encouraging ways in which the Gospel enriches their daily walk with God by serving others. Prior to the performance, classic Gospel recordings softly play until this charismatic group took the stage and lifted their voices for the bright and catchy original opening number, Traveling Shoes followed by the encouraging classic gospel hymn, How I Get Over. Traveling Shoes showcased skilled and powerful voices and it may be the acoustics of the venue, but vocal accompiament occasionally overpowered the lead singer.

Adorned in pearls and sophisticated black and white formal attire from ceremonial gloves right down to their shining shoes, this impressive cast is composed of two local performers and an array of cast members that flew in from California for this event. Traveling Shoes is an original work in progress and combines a tapestry of original and classic gospel songs, hymns and spirituals to demonstrate the power of the Gospel in their daily lives while finding strength during hard times.

Tiffany Binion, Doris Bumpus, Christian David & Levetta Hallin ‘Traveling Shoes’ Photo by Najee Brown

Many of the featured songs are upbeat and lively while others venture into soul stirring experiences and it is difficult to pick out ones that stand out over the others. One of the most quietly stirring moments in the production was a beautiful rendition of Peace Be Still, delivered powerfully by Michael Bradley, Dermel Warren, Tiffany Binion, and Yardley Griffin, Jr. Yardley Griffin, Jr’s You Gotta Move offers urgency in line with the musical’s core theme as well as an incredible version of At the Cross with Yardley Griffin and the cast. Dermel Warren with Christian David, Levetta Hall and Tiffany Binion deliver an inspiring rendition of Mary, Don’t You Weep as well as Were You There by Michael Bradley.

While more of a music showcase than a true narrative, Traveling Shoes delivers classic gospel hymns and spirituals including Give me that Old Time Religion featuring Christian David and the cast, Jamehl Taylor performs Oh When the Saints Go Marching In/This Little Light of Mine medley, Christian David and Yardley Griffin, Jr. perform a lighthearted and hopeful rendition of Swing Low, Sweet Chariot, a powerful His Eye is on the Sparrow by Doris Bumpus and Darren Paul and the entire company for a captivating Amazing Grace.

Doris Bumpus in ‘Traveling Shoes’ Photo by Najee Brown

Various life scenarios run through the production notably a wonderful rendition of Didn’t It Rain featuring Doris Bumpus and Levetta Hall.

Traveling Shoes references and briefly highlights the church pianist and that memorable pastor who makes an impact during the performance. Both individuals carry burdens and it would be interesting to expand on that idea and more than offering a song, insert a particular message that stands out apart from the music that would appeal to those who do not frequent the church pews. Traveling Shoes is a wonderful presentation for a church audience, but expanding on that idea to bring encouragement to those not familiar with the church may make the production that much more extraordinary.

This musical revue offers lightheartedness and humor while it also touches upon historical tragedies and injustices and how to cope when there is no answer. It works well as a segment and perhaps be expanded upon during different intervals of the production staying in line with the Traveling Shoes theme.

Yardley Griffin, Jr in ‘Traveling Shoes’ Photo by Najee Brown

Moonbox Productions presented a musical called Crowns which explores several themes including the significance of church hats as a symbol of much more while running a narrative through that. Though Traveling Shoes is a metaphor, it resonates at key points during the production. I do believe there can also be a story that can run through this, perhaps adding a protagonist surrounded by the company. The viewer can witness the protagonist on a journey of discovery who may be a first-time attendee at the church perhaps wearing the shoes while keeping the theme prevalent throughout the production.

“We declare victory before we see it.”

Traveling Shoes is a multifaceted music revue guaranteed to encourage, uplift and bring hope in these troubled times. It may stay with you long after the production is over.

Christian David & Yardley Griffin in ‘Traveling Shoes’ Photo by Najee Brown

Click here to learn more about C David Entertainment presented Traveling Shoes: A Revival of Sound, Soul and Story and for future performances.

REVIEW: North Shore Music Theatre’s ‘Rock of Ages’ packs big dreams and spectacle into daring wry rock nostalgia

Posted on 22 Days Ago by The Sleepless Critic

Break out the crimped hair, fishnets, rhinestones, pleather, mullets, mutton chops and more. Rock of Ages rewinds the clock to the electric and hair-centric 80s.

Back when Rock of Ages was celebrating the tenth anniversary of its Broadway premiere in 2019, the Bourbon Room opened as a real bar and nightclub inspired by the legendary fictional bar and nightclub in jukebox musical Rock of Ages. Though it recently closed down, if it contained half the wild antics of this edgy musical, it would have been quite the trip.

With lively direction by Kevin P. Hill, hair-raising music direction by Peter Leigh-Nilsen, and rambunctiously choreographed by Sara Andreas, North Shore Music Theatre continues Rock of Ages live and in person at North Shore Music Theatre in Beverly, Massachusetts through Sunday, August 23. Unbridled and untamed, this suggestive and semi-interactive theatre in the round musical contains mature humor and content and the action is not limited to the stage. Click here for more information and for tickets.

We’ve come a long way since the 80s and Rock of Ages serves as a reminder of how things have changed, especially for women. A jukebox rock musical, Rock of Ages is best enjoyed as an extended MTV music video at a time back when music videos were mainly performed on the popular platform. The rock medleys have cheek, sass, abandon and air guitar. While the real world oozes with serious drama, Rock of Ages is meant as pure entertainment and the cast really sinks their teeth into each over the top character representing a freer and bolder time.

Packed with colorful characters doused with a mix of rock raunchiness and self aware humor, Rock of Ages holds a mirror up to the era of excess and distinct self expression. Steering this club is Matt DaSilva who is impressive as Lonny, the Bourbon’s impulsive no-holds-barred manager, resident storyteller, and sometimes lewd yet fun loving narrator. DaSilva’s strong vocals and penchant for dark, self-aware humor, pop culture references and musical commentary work well in a script that never takes itself too seriously. In a blond beard and sunglasses which seem right out of 38 Special, Evan Harrington excellently delivers relaxed charm and dry humor as lovable Dennis Dupre, owner of the Bourbon Room. DaSilva and Harrington share an easy rapport and an unabashed loyalty toward the Bourbon Room and rock and roll.

Evan Harrington (Dennis) and Matt DaSilva (Lonny) in “Rock of Ages” at Bill Hanney’s North Shore Music Theatre from August 12 – August 23, 2026. Photo © Paul Lyden

Part love story, part rebellion, and mostly power rock musical, Rock of Ages is set in 1987 on California’s Sunset Strip where idealistic small town girl Sherrie (Chelsea Williams) and guitar strumming dreamer Drew (EJ Dohring) long for stardom and are not sure where to start. They set their sights inside the fledgling Bourbon Room, an aging nightclub and bar in danger of being shut down unless someone takes action.

Under neon and gleaming spotlights by José Santiago, Jeffrey D. Kmiec’s glitzy set design showcases a number of locations on the Sunset Strip lined with guitars on a jungle patterned rotating stage which includes the legendary Tower Records, seedy Venus Strip Club, Dupre’s Bourbon Room and a certain graffiti nightclub bathroom stall in the distance where you can almost feel the grime. Rebecca Glick’s nostalgic costumes rise to the challenge, running the gamut from bold rock T-shirts to scantily clad to jazzercise and everywhere in between.

The cast of “Rock of Ages” at Bill Hanney’s North Shore Music Theatre from August 12 – August 23, 2026. Photo © Paul Lyden

Performed by costumed musicians ready to rock led by Peter Leigh-Nilson, Rock of Ages is fueled by a wide array of 80’s hits that are clearly a trip down memory lane for some including Journey, Bon Jovi, REO Speedwagon, and Foreigner driven by athletic, slick and over the top moves including pole choreography by Meadow Nguy.

Chelsea Williams is a soaring soprano as wide-eyed yet determined Sherrie and does a terrific job teaming up with Toneisha Harris as complex yet confident Justice in a powerful medley of Quarterflash’s Harden My Heart and Pat Benatar’s Shadows of the Night. Harris boasts powerhouse vocals and would have liked to have heard more from her. Williams also shines in a sweet yet intense rendition with Dohring for Extreme’s More than Words, Bad English’s To Be with You, and Warrant’s Heaven medley which includes a surprise chorus as well as powerful harmony for Damn Yankees’ High Enough.

Chelsea Williams (Sherrie) and EJ Dohring (Drew) in “Rock of Ages” at Bill Hanney’s North Shore Music Theatre from August 12 – August 23, 2026. Photo © Paul Lyden

In cherry red glasses, Lily Kauffman gives off Cheri OTeri comedic vibes as spunky and resourceful renegade Regina. In hippie fringe, she’s all spirit, heart and hilarity for Twisted Sister’s We’re Not Gonna Take it, an amusing rendition of Starship’s We Built this City and Styx’s Too Much Time on My Hands with Tom Galantich as Hertz and Michael Schimmele as Franz and the cast. Schimmele offers some refreshing and sometimes goofy comic relief as naïve Franz and Galantich is of a sterner variety but they both play well off each other, especially featuring a certain wrecking ball in Europe’s The Final Countdown.

With strong vocals and a large ego, Nathaniel Hackman makes a grand entrance as mysterious and charismatic Stacy Jaxx in chaps, cowboy hat and female entourage (in a nod to another famous 80s rocker) to Bon Jovi’s Dead or Alive.

That is just a taste of the wide range of rock numbers in store. The musical is not for everyone, but you may find yourself bobbing your head, singing along, or perhaps a bit stunned at the performances and the catchy tunes you may or may not have lived through, but nonetheless have stood the test of time in their own way. What is great about music is you might change, but the song remains the same.

North Shore Music Theatre continues Rock of Ages live and in person at North Shore Music Theatre in Beverly, Massachusetts through Sunday, August 23. Click here for more information and for tickets.

REVIEW: True North and Exiled Theatre’s ‘M. Refractions from an Evil Act’

Posted on 25 Days Ago by The Sleepless Critic

A man disoriented on the floor and a door seemingly with a mind of its own.

A sophisticated Parisian hotel holds a lot more than secrets in James Wilkinson’s M: Refractions from an Evil Act. Is this place escape or a trap?

With unpredictable direction by Joe Juknievich, Exiled Theatre recently presented the world premiere of mystery thriller drama, M: Refractions from an Evil Act live and in person at Boston Playwrights’ Theatre in Boston, Massachusetts through Sunday, August 9. This bilingual production in French and English contained some adult themes and was part of Boston University’s Boston Playwrights’ Theatre’s Incubator productions. It ran 2 hours with a 15 minute intermission. Click here for more information.

Peter Tone and Julia Hertzberg in ‘M: Refractions from an Evil Act’ Photo credit: Morganna Becker

With a classic soundtrack that added a vintage flair, M. Refractions from an Evil Act is an intriguing production that does a lot in its two hour run time. It reaches into a realm of possibilities such as time travel, paranormal activity, possession, loneliness, guilt, and grief when a mysterious woman claims an intruder was in her hotel room. However, when her claims, sordid history and circumstances for being in Paris suspiciously change on a dime, she becomes a person of interest that cannot be trusted.

Julia Hertzberg and Peter Tone in ‘M: Refractions from an Evil Act’ Photo credit: Morganna Becker

Glamorously dressed in a blue romper with a coordinated scarf, Julia Hertzberg as seemingly self-centered “M” is one moment lonely, the next sharing her grim thoughts and then overwhelmed, disoriented and frustrated at her ordeal wishing to drown her sorrows. However, this is no ordinary hotel and the people around her have secrets of their own.

Out of the characters presented, Peter Tone is the most likable as a Hotel Clerk. Tone is instantly accommodating, genuinely concerned and a sincere listener with good chemistry with Hertzberg’s M while Sydney Grant as brisk, determined, genteel and no nonsense Jolene is laser focused on cleanliness and order. Grant as Jolene and Hertzberg as M share an intense dynamic while M’s relationship with Tim Hoover as Lone is a striking puzzle. As soon as things start to become clearer, more and more questions arise.

Tim Hoover and Peter Tone in ‘M: Refractions from an Evil Act’ Photo credit: Morganna Becker.

Producer and costume designer Laura Crook Waxdal delivers chic Parisian style in attire which includes coat and tails, a classic French maid uniform and tailored suit with a brimmed hat. Nick Duffy’s flickering lighting design lends to the production’s suspense and enlivens Joe Juknievich’s foreboding set depicting a historic hotel room with wooden furnishings.

M does not know and is not interested in learning French and much of the production is in French without translation perhaps to put the audience in M’s shoes. For those who understand French, you are in the right place. However, it does make this already complex show more difficult to follow.

Sydney Grant and Julia Hertzberg in ‘M: Refractions from an Evil Act’ Photo credit: Morganna Becker

This production was inspired by the playwright’s bizarre three-day Parisian weekend and I wish I knew more about that experience. Though this thrilling production boasts a lineup of compelling characters while delivering a chilling vibe somewhere between Twilight Zone and Hitchcock with a cryptic sense of humor, it also spends a lot of time deciding the direction of its narrative. This work in progress touches on a lot of themes presented seemingly out of sequence yet does not fully commit to them. There’s loss, crime, revenge, special effects and even some mind tricks and while I love a good mystery and appreciate the concept, so many elements are left to interpretation which becomes confusing and frustrating. The show offers so many possibilities, but leaves more questions than answers.

Exiled Theatre recently presented the world premiere mystery thriller drama, M: Refractions from an Evil Act live and in person at Boston Playwrights Theatre in Boston, Massachusetts through Sunday, August 9. Click here for more information.

REVIEW: Company Theatre delivers a radical ‘Jagged Little Pill’

Posted on August 11 by The Sleepless Critic

Beware that seemingly perfect little Christmas card and newsletter in the mail. There is often so much more to the story.

One musician with a gift for reading between the lines is Grammy award-winning alternative rock singer-songwriter Alanis Morissette who teams up with like minded Academy and Tony award-winning writer Diablo Cody for Jagged Little Pill the Musical in which Cody went on to win a Tony Award for Best Book of a Musical.

Don’t expect to see an Alanis autobiography in Jagged Little Pill, but this ruminating musical rather integrates themes from her songs into a cautionary tale about a family rife with secrets and resentment unavoidably brimming to the surface.

Bobby Atkinson, Dana Sullivan, Todd Merritt and Nikita DaRosa in Company Theatre’s ‘Jagged Little Pill’ Photo courtesy of Zoe Bradford

Under Zoe Bradford and Sally Ashton Forrest’s keen co-direction, Jasmine Dillon’s pulsating and interconnected choreography as well as Robert McDonough’s agile music direction, Company Theatre continues their 46^th season with Alanis Morissette’s Jagged Little Pill the Musical live and in person through Sunday, August 16 at The Company Theatre in Norwell, Massachusetts. It runs approximately two hours and 40 minutes with one intermission and has some mature themes. Click here for more information, for tickets and here for more information on how you can support the Company Theatre’s Project Stage Restoration.

With music by Alanis Morissette and Glen Ballard, an intimate eight piece orchestra delivers synthetic ballads and searing rhythms led by music director Robert McDonough. The setting is as lively and urgent as the musical’s pacing. Dean Palmer Jr. rhapsodically illuminates Ryan Barrow’s rolling and fold out house-inspired set while projection designer Jack Gruman artistically brings to life a gritty, skewed and occasionally kaleidoscopic view of a Connecticut suburb. Gruman enhances a variety of locations including a coffee house, office space, a tumultuous storm window, an array of family photos and fireworks.

The cast and orchestra of Company Theatre’s ‘Jagged Little Pill’ Photo courtesy of Zoe Bradford

Jagged Little Pill is an intriguing exploration that addresses something that runs rampant in our society. It is the desire and pressure to be perfect or at least looking that way to others. The idea did not originate with social media, but it has intensified that desire often to a crippling degree.

Mary Jane Healy, richly depicted by Dana Sullivan, hides those imperfections in a smug holiday letter alongside the Healy Christmas card, but not ironically, the façade quickly fades in getting to know her seemingly successful family over a one year period. ‘The truth is too hard,’ MJ reflects.

Dana Sullivan and the cast of Company Theatre’s ‘Jagged Little Pill’ Photo courtesy of Zoe Bradford

Many of the ensemble cast members demonstrate a modern Greek chorus observing and occasionally contributing to the plot skillfully taking on multiple roles or acting as the musical’s conscience. Some of their messages are unmistakable while others are left to interpretation. Though the musical is set in present day, it boasts a bit of a 90s flair. From The Who to Talking Heads to AC/DC to Green Day, Kiera O’Connor sets the musical’s edgy tone dressing the young cast in rock-n roll-inspired 90s grunge costumes including black starred stockings, tied flannel shirts and converse sneakers while the adults are adorned in classic and casual chic attire.

The cast of Company Theatre’s ‘Jagged Little Pill’ Photo courtesy of Zoe Bradford

Jagged Little Pill dials into a number of social issues including addictions, isolation, coming of age, LGBTQ, rape, marital strife and more while exploring significant and complex relationships. Sullivan brings savvy and intensity to Mary Jane who is easier to grow frustrated with than a source of sympathy, but Sullivan manages to accomplish both as the plot thickens. Her exceptional expectations are rooted in trauma, exposing her vulnerability in a stirring version of Smiling and later in a chilling rendition of Uninvited boosted by Claudia McMahon as a spiraling lead dancer among other roles. Bobby Atkinson skillfully depicts Mary Jane’s son, Nick Healy, making it easy to feel the gravity, mounting pressure and clashing intentions with Sullivan’s Mary Jane.

Nikita DaRosa (center0 and the cast of Company Theatre’s ‘Jagged Little Pill’ Photo courtesy of Zoe Bradford

Nikita DeRosa as Frankie Healy and Emma Keane as Jo Taylor are both powerful vocalists delivering a playful duet of Hand in My Pocket. With tenacity and soaring vocals, Nikita DaRosa as Frankie has no interest in being perfect, but rather longing to be heard. A passionate activist who was adopted by the Healy family, DaRosa’s Frankie candidly contributes to her family’s reflections in a curt and frank rendition of All I Really Want and an affecting rendition of That I Would be Good with Emma Keane as Jo Taylor and Charlie Solari as mysterious Phoenix.

Emma Keane and the cast of Company Theatre’s ‘Jagged Little Pill’ Photo courtesy of Zoe Bradford

Though a few of Morissette’s tunes lose some of its bite in musical translation, Morissette’s You Oughta Know never loses its ferocity, especially within Emma Keane’s steely and stellar rendition.

Though Jagged Little Pill tackles its share of somber topics, it also boasts lighthearted humor in an unexpected version of Ironic, an effervescent So Pure and a sweet and mellifluous duet of Head Over Feet.

Dana Sullivan, Natalie Spear Claudia McMahon and the cast of Company Theatre’s ‘Jagged Little Pill’ Photo courtesy of Zoe Bradford

As a massive Alanis Morissette fan dating back when she was a child actor in Canada, Morissette has been open about her battles with anxiety and depression. Her struggles infuse a unique depth into her resonating rock anthems which expose hidden truths that can make you angry, bring you to tears or both. Though I do not have the anger I did when I first heard Morissette’s music, she still presents emerging and ongoing reasons to be frustrated with the world. Some of the musical’s messages can be a little heavy handed because it tackles so much, but her hopeful takeaway always ring true. Be bold, authentic and speak up for what is right even if it is uncomfortable or less than perfect.

Bobby Atkinson and the cast of Company Theatre’s ‘Jagged Little Pill’

The Company Theatre continues their 46^th season with Alanis Morissette’s Jagged Little Pill the Musical live and in person through Sunday, August 16 at the Company Theatre in Norwell, Massachusetts. Click here for more information, for tickets and here for more information on how you can support the Company Theatre’s Project Stage Restoration.

REVIEW: Commonwealth Shakespeare Company vividly envisions a spirited ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’ on Boston Common

Posted on August 5 by The Sleepless Critic

Summer love is alive and well in vivid color on Boston Common.

Featuring a strong cast of renowned local performers and vocalists, Commonwealth Shakespeare Company captures the look and vibrant color of love in William Shakespeare’s classic A Midsummer Night’s Dream.

With intricate direction by Steven Maler, Commonwealth Shakespeare Company rings in their thirtieth season with William Shakespeare’s classic comedy A Midsummer Night’s Dream for free live and in person through Sunday, August 9 on the Common in Boston, Massachusetts. Though Amy Rubin’s set is partially likened to a children’s playground, this night production is not for children. The action is not limited to the stage, boasts valuable captions and runs 2 hours and 40 minutes with an intermission. I witnessed the production on CSC’s ASL night on August 2. Click here for more information and reservations.

De’Lon Grant* (Theseus) and Nora Eschenheimer* (Hippolyta). Photo Credit: Nile Scott Studios.

It is not difficult to see why A Midsummer Night’s Dream is one of Shakespeare’s most performed and beloved plays. It is everything but tragic and can be interpreted in a variety of ways featuring magic, mischief, romantic comedy, music, action and much more.

A Midsummer Night’s Dream has multiple story lines, but the cast translates Shakespeare’s work with a lively affinity for the text while infusing improvisation and pop culture references along the way. Part play within a play, part fantasy, and part comedy, A Midsummer Night’s Dream essentially explores love in all of its forms from unrequited to desire to true love to romantic comedy gone awry due to some mystical love potions. Shakespeare’s witty dialogue is an intriguing reminder that his classic story lines translate seamlessly into a wide variety of contemporary scenarios.

Nora Eschenheimer* (Titania) and The Company of A Midsummer Night’s Dream. Photo Credit: Nile Scott Studios.

A Midsummer Night’s Dream is also the source of some of Shakespeare’s most famous reflections on love such as ‘True love does not see with the eyes, but the mind’ and ‘The course of true love never did run smooth.’ Scenic designer Amy Rubin also emblazons Shakespeare’s immortal words about mortals and fools into the very fabric of the production’s multi-tiered and industrial scaffold set. Rubin certainly provides the wow factor in a heart shaped and layered set which is a cross between a playground and a night club complete with slide and ball pit as a glimmering disco ball hangs overhead. Maximo Grano de Oro illuminates this wild landscape with active and multicolored glee as the flashing lighting pursues the actors to the beat of the production’s contemporary music. Costumers Brooke Stanton and Rachel Padula-Shufelt mix glimmering Athenian-inspired costumes with 80s and steam punk flair. The ensembles range from refined and upscale in achromatic classic suits to splashy, florescent, glimmering, tinsel and feathered club wear which includes fringe jackets, cowboy boots, ornamental robes, fingerless studded gloves and bejeweled gold caps. The constantly playful and bold neon fairies seem pulled right out of a 80s night club in glowing ethereal wings and combat boots. Sound designer Ted Kearnan brings a contemporary vibe with a mix of original and popular upbeat rhythms built for comic relief as well as setting the scene.

Nick Cearley as Puck in Commonwealth Shakespeare Company’s ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’ Photo by Nile Scott Studios

Coy, roguish and often lighthearted, Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream establishes a world of status and fantasy featuring a cast of powerful and compelling characters often hysterically determined to fight for what they want and will do whatever it takes for a laugh demonstrated by Paul Melendy as slick and bombastic Nick Bottom from exacting accents to integrating a well placed Shrek reference. Putting on a lovely Romanian accent, thick beaded necklace and large red glasses while wielding a ridiculous plastic sword, Karen MacDonald is delightfully unrecognizable as resourceful and charismatic Quince among a group of madcap and dedicated mechanicals including Brooks Reeves as a knitting Robin Starveling who offer more than their fair share of silly humor and bright ideas before the final curtain.

Brooks Reeves (Robin Starveling), Michael Broadhurst* (Francis Flute), Paul Melendy* (Nick Bottom), Karen MacDonald* (Petra Quince), Alex Leondedis (Snug), and John Kuntz* (Snout). Photo Credit: Nile Scott Studios.

Some of this robust cast takes on dual roles which impressively shows off their range. Jaime José Hernández as love struck Lysander shares jubilant adoration and endearing chemistry with Meghan Carey as sweet Hermia, but also has a chance to explore another side of this character. In spiked hair and glimmering Athenian gear, Nick Cearley keeps the mischief flowing as prankster Puck conspiring with De’Lon Grant who adds gravitas to Theseus and Oberon for a string of seemingly harmless pranks.

De’Lon Grant* (Oberon) and Nick Cearley* (Puck). Photo Credit: Nile Scott Studios

Nora Eschenheimer takes on dual roles as sophisticated Hippolyta as well as commanding and seductive Titania. Carey is charming as headstrong Hermia while Annika Burley is comically relentless as crazy in love and wildly frustrated Helena going to arduous lengths to get what she wants. Burley’s Helena shares impetuous moments with Hernández as Lysander and Jack Greenberg as impulsive Demetrius navigated by carefully timed choreography. Another highlight shows off Burely and Carey’s sharp comic wit during another confrontation when love goes awry.

Annika Burley (Helena) with Jaime José Hernández* (Lysander) and Jack Greenberg*(Demetrius). Photo Credit: Nile Scott Studios.

Though the production can be a bit lengthy, Commonwealth Shakespeare Company’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream is a fun way to spend a summer evening under the stars. This vivacious production continues live and in person through Sunday, August 9 on the Boston Common. Click here for more information and reservations.

REVIEW: Retail therapy takes on new meaning in Hub Theatre Company of Boston’s lighthearted comedy ‘Buyer and Cellar’

Posted on July 29 by The Sleepless Critic

“Well, hello gorgeous.”

What does an unemployed and rather desperate actor and a wealthy multi-talented celebrity have in common?

They share a kit kat bar and a dream.

Exploring the psyche of the have and have nots, Jonathan Tolins’s fictional one man comedy, Buyer and Cellar brings to light the weighty and wild world of excess on the journey of discovering what is truly important.

Victor L. Shopov in Hub Theatre Company of Boston’s ‘Buyer and Cellar’ Photo credit Lauren Elias

With lighthearted direction by Daniel Bourque, Hub Theatre Company of Boston continues Buyer and Cellar live and in person at Club Café in Boston, Massachusetts through Saturday, August 1. The action is not limited to the stage and runs approximately 100 minutes with no intermission. Pay-what-you-can tickets are available. The production occasionally contains adult and unfiltered language. Purchase a drink during this show and Club Café offers a full menu. Click here for more information and for tickets.

Victor L, Shopov in Hub Theatre Company of Boston’s ‘Buyer and Cellar’ Photo by Lauren Elias

Buyer and Cellar is a fictional tale, but is based on real life aspects of Barbara Streisand’s life drawn from Streisand’s book, My Passion for Design which sits on a lighted pedestal. Streisand’s book offers insight into her legacy and the story behind building her dream home. While the show revolves around Barbara Streisand, you do not necessarily need to be a fan to appreciate this production.

From Funny Girl to Yentl, sound designer Gage Baker weaves inflections of Streisand’s most memorable film theme songs into the playful and whimsical sound design. Under a sparkling disco ball, Club Café always offers a little extra in its vibrant space and Justin Lahue takes full advantage of that space through the tiered set and surrounding projections scattered throughout Club Café’s back room. A variety of projections include some of Streisand’s most coveted and iconic ensembles, store fronts, book racks and a peek into the architecture from the book. Two vintage wardrobe stands ostentatiously adorned and topped off with a pink feather boa situated side by side for colorful ambiance and a sophisticated chair and ottoman is a wink to Barbara’s style.

One of the most fascinating aspects and the center of this production is that Barbara Streisand built a shopping mall in the cellar of her Malibu mansion in the late 2000s.

Yes, really. It’s mindboggling to think Streisand has that many possessions and all the more intriguing are the eccentric stories behind them. With a wealth of pop culture references and self aware humor, Victor L. Shopov amicably portrays down-on-his-luck California actor Alex More who has had just about enough working for Disneyland and is looking for his big break. Central Casting arranges a bizarre new opportunity in which Alex is tapped by gravelly throated estate manager Sharon to become the shopping mall’s very first employee. Confusion, havoc, mystery and even monotony ensue on the job before Alex is face-to-face with Streisand herself.

Shopov is a candid and engaging storyteller infusing animated and eccentric voices emphasizing various mannerisms and avoiding impressions. He perfects a mix of imaginative and real life voices with flair including a humorous and exacting take on Barbara delicately sampling a morsel of food with her incomparably long nails. Navigating between awestruck, sarcastic, earnest and dubious, Shopov’s Alex takes this amusing and outrageous journey through Streisand’s wonderland through panic and in stride. However, nothing beats Shopov’s hilarious talent for narrating and delivering commentary on one particular film that won’t be revealed here.

Victor L. Shopov and Barbara in Hub Theatre Company of Boston’s ‘Buyer and Cellar’ Photo by Lauren Elias

Buyer and Cellar is a funny tale about another side of a legend. One may long to be rich. However, not everything is what is seems, even for someone who seems to have it all.

Hub Theatre Company of Boston continues Buyer and Cellar live and in person at Club Café in Boston, Massachusetts through Saturday, August 1. Click here for more information and for tickets.

REVIEW: Things more than go bump in the night in gripping ‘Paranormal Activity’

Posted on July 23 by The Sleepless Critic

Full Disclosure: I saw Paranormal Activity Live on Stage alone.

Not necessarily a fan of horror with few exceptions, my interests lean more towards thought-provoking science fiction or a psychological thriller. I was hesitant as I arrived at Emerson Colonial Theatre facing a black curtain, but left riveted by the production’s depth, intensity, and a truly remarkable cast.

Paranormal Activity can be chilling, but is also rooted squarely in the human condition with a great deal of darkly relatable humor and lots of twists and turns. It lured me in and never let go.

Superbly directed by Felix Barrett, Levi Halloway’s Paranormal Activity Live on Stage continues its pre-Broadway run through Thursday, July 30 at Emerson Colonial Theatre in Boston, Massachusetts. For the squeamish, this intense and immersive production is not gory. It does contain explicit language, some dark themes and runs two hours and 20 minutes with one intermission. Click here for more information and for tickets.

Cher Álvarez and Travis A. Knight in Paranormal Activity. Photo by Teresa Castracane Photography.

Metal, alternative and hard rock 90s music from musicians such as Soundgarden revs up the audience before the production begins. Paranormal Activity Live on Stage is considered a new story from the original film which inspired six sequels. A seventh film sequel has an anticipated 2027 release date. The original film latched onto the clunky, grainy and less polished amateur film style of The Blair Witch Project which enjoyed great success at the time.

However, the stage production greatly improves on the film predecessor in multiple ways. The film has a grainy home video quality, but this production is all encompassing and in vibrant color. Having witnessed the original film, the Paranormal Activity play is more effective, allowing the audience to experience multiple scenarios at once led with sterling timing by lighting designer Anna Watson. Scenic and costume designer Fly Davis crafts an elaborate and functional dual level house which includes five detailed and sophisticated rooms featuring a modern kitchen, hanging plants and a smart flat screen television. Illusion designer Chris Fisher, the illusionist behind Harry Potter and the Cursed Child on Broadway, creates plenty of riveting moments that will have you fully invested in what will happen next.

Cher Álvarez in Paranormal Activity. Photo by Kyle Flubacker.

Contributing to the production’s unfettered tension, Gareth Fry’s mesmerizing sound design ranges from a steely and hollow hum to sudden rings to what can be likened to a deafening and reverberating wind tunnel.

This engaging cast is so in sync and polished that they will make you almost forget you are watching a horror stage play. Cher Álvarez as Lou Singer and Travis A. Knight as James Singer are incredibly charming as a newly married couple who have just moved into a house in London. Playful with a dynamic sense of humor, Álvarez and Knight demonstrate a heartwarming and genuine connection as they embrace and warmly support each other.

Shannon Cochran is impressive as James’s religious and pushy southern mother who only wants what is best for her son and Eva Kaminsky is captivating as an eerie and insightful famous podcaster Etheline Cotgrave.

Paranormal Activity boasts many darkly funny moments while also delving into serious issues such as depression, trauma, secrets, marital challenges, spiritual warfare and much more with a wealth of unpredictable twists and turns. At one point, this fully invested audience (including me) was at the edge of our seats rooting on the characters and united in the action. Although I came alone to the production, I did not feel alone with this intense and excited crowd.

Isn’t that what live theatre is all about?

Levi Halloway’s Paranormal Activity Live on Stage continues its pre-Broadway run live and in person at Emerson Colonial Theatre in Boston, Massachusetts through Thursday, July 30. Click here for more information and for tickets.

REVIEW: Silence speaks volumes in Gloucester Stage Company’s clever and multi-faceted British play ‘Betrayal’

Posted on July 20 by The Sleepless Critic

“I think of you sometimes.”

The passing thought and echoes of an ex can come and go. In the aftermath of an affair, some things may also become crystal clear.

With layered direction by Shana Gozansky, Gloucester Stage Company continues Harold Pinter’s British drama, Betrayal live and in person at Gloucester Stage Company in Gloucester, Massachusetts through Saturday, August 1. This semi-autobiographical and non-linear production runs approximately 85 minutes with no intermission. Click here for more information and for tickets.

Gloucester Stage Company’s production of “Betrayal”, written by Harold Pinter and directed by Shana Gozansky, starring Liza Giangrande, Michael Underhill, Tanner Efinger, and Jeremy Beazlie, runs at the theater from July 11 though August 1, 2026.

© 2026 Shawn G. Henry • 978-590-4869

GSC-Betrayal-260708_004

Written in 1978, Harold Pinter’s Betrayal is a deeply personal play inspired by Pinter’s illicit real life affair with a BBC journalist. It delves into the lies, danger, suspicions, surprises, and secrets you hide from others as well as the ones you tell yourself when love takes an unexpected turn. I couldn’t help but notice the British holiday film, Love Actually shares a passing resemblance to Betrayal in one of its many popular plot lines and famous playwright Jason Robert Brown was inspired to pattern Pinter’s reverse chronological narrative style in Betrayal into his famous musical, The Last Five Years. Instead of building a story from the beginning, Pinter innovatively begs the question, “How did we all get here?”

Jeffrey Petersen’s intriguing avant guarde set serves as various locations featuring white chairs, a pastel background, a skewed mirror and red carpeting. While Amanda E. Fallon’s flashing shadows, silhouettes and psychedelic lighting in conjunction with Julian Crocamo’s jagged piano-infused sound design reverberates to rewind the clock, it is curious that the audience can bear witness to pieces of the action backstage. Perhaps an act of transparency in this complicated affair.

Time leaping from 1977 to 1968, Betrayal redefines and explores the nature of betrayal in all its forms. This witty cast share captivating chemistry and sharp comic timing. Liza Giangrande depicts romantic, complicated and disillusioned Emma who is married to Tanner Efinger as scholarly book publisher Robert, but sees an opportunity for freedom in Michael Underhill as dashing, married, and Robert’s oldest friend and fellow book publisher Jerry. Rounding out the cast is Jeremy Beazile who offers his own humor as the Waiter. Aside from an immense love of literature, Giangrande is compelling as Emma sharing playful and exciting chemistry with Underhill as Jerry and an enigmatic and restrained rapport with Robert.

Nia Safaar Banks creates posh ensembles not only faithful to the late 70s in psychedelic patterns, floral, and velvet coats, but creations that reflect the distinct personalities and vast differences in one another which is never better defined than in Michael Underhill as relaxed Jerry and Tanner Efinger as intellectual Robert. In sneakers and denim, Jerry is adventurous, dark and dashing while Robert is anxious, serious and seemingly safe in a distinguished sweater vest.

Pinter’s eccentric style of storytelling is always fascinating even at its most absurd which also exposes pointlessness, but here Pinter relies more on subtlety than absurdity. It is a production with a deeply meticulously restrained emotional core. Distressed sighs, ironies, layered conversations, loaded pauses, and the dignified and carefully composed comments are the real allure of this production embedded within Betrayal’s scandal. Betrayal is eccentrically understated with a wealth of humor, repression, symbolism, contradictions and revelations in an innovatively told tale. It takes a novel approach to each scene, especially the lack of awkwardness where it should be awkward and the profound meaning behind what is left unsaid.

Gloucester Stage Company continues Harold Pinter’s British drama, Betrayal live and in person at Gloucester Stage Company in Gloucester, Massachusetts through Sunday, Saturday, August 1. Click here for more information and for tickets.