Mix in a dash of the Tony award-winning musical, Rent, a hint of HBO’s hit show, Sex and the City, and stir in the thought-provoking film, Sliding Doors, and what emerges is a real treat in Cohasset Dramatic Club’s musical drama, If/Then. Set in New York City and based on a book by Tom Kitt, If/Then is an unpredictable, immersive tale that explores destiny, love, happiness, and the complexity of navigating through life’s surprises.
Cohasset Dramatic Club is thrilled to be the first in the US to present this stirring, humorous musical after its professional Broadway run and national tour. Directed by Lisa Pratt and technically directed by Mark Bono, If/Then continues at Cohasset Town Hall in Cohasset, Massachusetts through Saturday, March 25. Click here for more information and tickets.
Is the path to happiness completely random or is destiny derived from the right choices? Elizabeth Vaughn, portrayed masterfully by Ann McCoy, is a successful urban planner who decides to make a fresh start in New York City. Everyone seems to think they know what is best for her, which helps lead Elizabeth onto two, unexpected paths.
Featuring a vibrant cast with realistic conflicts and fleshed out characters, Ann McCoy as conflicted, soulful Elizabeth Vaughn is the heart of the show, a meaty role originated by Idina Menzel on Broadway. Dressed in a sharp black pants suit, McCoy is more than up to the challenge, portraying a woman who was once certain of life’s direction, but lately, her confidence has waned. McCoy impressively depicts Elizabeth’s cautiousness through a shift in her eyes and yet, also brings out the character’s lively impulsiveness. She heeds other people’s advice, but ultimately follows her heart. A soprano, Ann McCoy’s vocals dip and soar, hitting challenging notes with ease. This is especially evident in the numbers, You Learn to Live Without and Always Starting Over.
One of McCoy’s greatest strengths is the natural, unique chemistry she shares with each cast member. Elizabeth is single, but not lonely. Michelle Margulies portrays Kate’s incredibly charming and outspoken friend. Margulies as Kate is engaging, fun-loving, and a bit of a scene stealer. She is Elizabeth’s biggest fan and only has her best interests at heart. Perpetually optimistic, Margulies offers a soulful and comical rendition of the number, It’s a Sign, playfully engaging the crowd.
Ann McCoy and Michael Warner are local community talents known for various productions on the South Shore, shine in their roles. Michael Warner is compelling as caring, forthright, and unassuming army surgeon Josh, a man also clearly torn between two life choices. He delivers a touching rendition of the song, Hey Kid. Elizabeth and Josh’s chemistry is hopeful and passionate. They create great harmony together, especially during the song, Here I Go.
While Josh is practical, Ricky DeSisto is a natural as impulsive and endearing Lucas. With his earnest, idealistic nature and fair share of cynicism, one cannot help but root for him through life. Through lighthearted teasing and sweet glances, Elizabeth and Lucas have a warm, playful chemistry. Their song together, Some Other Me is moving. Rob Buckel-Gillis portrays hopeful, supportive David, a surgeon. He is hopeful, likable, and optimistic. Lucas and David share a tender duet, The Best Worst Mistake You Ever Made.
Elegantly dressed in a suit and tie, Mike Nakashima portrays Stephen, a complex character with mysterious intentions. Determined and serious, Stephen and Elizabeth share a career-minded camaraderie as he encourages her to follow her dreams, seeing her boundless potential.
With music and lyrics by Brian Yorkey, an intimate band including Music Director Sarah Troxler on piano, guitarist Jack Byrne, percussionist Michael Hobbs, bassist Jon Lay, Clarinet/Flute/Saxophone Glenn Silvia, and Cassie Sulbaran on Viola bring to life this upbeat, contemporary musical with a libretto. Clever blocking brings part of the band onstage.
Costume and props designer Irene Vifides lend to New York City’s urban vibe and signature style through big, designer purses, fashionable shoes, and impressive, colorful costumes that vary from sophisticated, city attire to a casual night in. Scenic artist Denise Feeney and Scenic projection designers Erin and Patrick Dzierzak and Dramatic Sounds create urban ambiance with recreated city sounds, black and white city skylines, and a wealth of broad, colorful landscapes depicting a few of New York City’s most famous landmarks. One of this show’s many highlights is the humorous depiction of NYC’s tiny apartments. Cohasset Dramatic Club brings to life a captivating musical depicting how complicated life can be and proving it’s also too short to miss If/Then.
Directed by Lisa Pratt, musically directed by Sarah Troxler, and choreographed by Tara Morrison, Cohasset Dramatic Club presents If/Then through March 25 at 7:30. All performances will be held at Cohasset Town Hall 41 Highland Ave in Cohasset, Massachusetts. Click here for more information and for tickets.
Other ways to support Cohasset Dramatic Club is to become a volunteer and make a donation. Sign up for their email list to learn about upcoming events and more. Click here for more about the Cohasset Dramatic Club and follow them on Facebook.