A surprise party goes awry and one ambitious investigator is on the scene.

With fast paced direction by Tyler Rosati and versatile music direction by Bethany Aiken, Greater Boston Stage Company continues murder mystery musical farce Murder for Two live and in person through Sunday, November 9 live at Greater Boston Stage Company in Stoneham, Massachusetts. This semi-interactive whodunit two hander is 90 minutes without an intermission.  Click here for more information and for tickets.

Katy Monthei’s vintage mansion setting creates a homey atmosphere which includes dated wallpaper, cluttered bookshelves, several mismatched lamps, various knickknacks on scattered shelving, Egyptian rugs, framed portraits and a sleek black piano all framed by incandescent theatrical bulbs. 

Jared Troilo is “aw shucks” charming as determined and inventive New England police officer Marcus who dreams of one day being promoted to detective.  What better way to impress his boss than to solve this small town murder mystery of who murdered famed novelist Arthur Whitney.

One of the brightest spots of this production is Troilo and Will McGarrahan’s sublime turns on the piano. Whether competing or complementing each other while making some amazing music together, this multi-talented duo sure know how to captivate an audience. Their madcap piano workings are creative and thrilling.  As they tickle the keys at brisk and elegant paces, the rhythms work with Cost’s dazzling lighting to elevate the show’s playful suspense and navigates the show’s various moods, new thoughts, and each of McGarrahan’s frequent transformations into various murder suspects from toddler to elder.  

The brisk musical elements boast vaudeville and vintage Broadway flair while satirizing the nature of musical theatre.  For example, a cell phone ringing onstage is hilariously mistaken for an audience member’s rudeness. 

It is also greatly entertaining watching this comedic duo share great chemistry occasionally making each other laugh and other times barely holding it together during the production’s sillier moments.  It is no small task to put a show on of this caliber and both rise to the occasion. Troilo is a straight man Dean Martin to McGarrahan’s Jerry Lewis as McGarrahan slips into various accents, mannerisms, and rapidly poses as numerous suspects using merely a prop or piece of wardrobe separating each distinct character thanks to Chelsea Kerl’s jocular costume design from a multicolor scarf to a feather boa to a pink tutu and even a cocktail umbrella.

However, the show’s infectious charm cannot entirely make up for and a muddled murder mystery plot.  Using only this dynamic duo, it is still difficult to picture the scene of the crime and not enough distinction separating the various suspects.  Picturing multiple people in the room and the blocking at times doesn’t quite make sense and would be better understood with more than two people.  When Greater Boston Stage Company presented the one man Sleepy Hollow classic, its narration seemed to drive the story more clearly and perhaps that is what is missing here.

This production is far funnier than suspenseful and not to be taken seriously and perhaps this is all part of the joke, but it became difficult and a little frustrating visualizing this intriguing murder mystery you are also trying to solve alongside Marcus.

Jared Troilo and Will McGarrahan are two bright talents and such likable characters and yet, following the plot is a challenge to say the least.  If you can put that aside, Murder for Two features a wonderfully likable and impressive duo for an amazing and lighthearted evening.

Greater Boston Stage Company continues murder mystery musical farce Murder for Two live and in person through Sunday, November 9 live at Greater Boston Stage Company in Stoneham, Massachusetts.  Click here for more information and for tickets.