REVIEW: Out of the shadows, North Shore Music Theatre presents a less frightening ‘Phantom’
Could Phantom still be a gothic mystery horror tale and yet be effervescent, tender, playful and uplifting? Could it also be an introspective musical that delves into love and family?
Why yes it could while adding unexpected elements and a new dimension to Gaston Leroux’s classic novel that works.
Viscerally directed by Robert W. Schneider with powerful music direction by Dale Reiling, Bill Hanney’s North Shore Music Theatre continues Yeston and Kopil’s Phantom live and in person at North Shore Music Theatre in Beverly, Massachusetts through Sunday, November 1. Based on Gaston Leroux’s classic novel, The Phantom of the Opera, this revolving theatre-in-the-round musical’s action is not limited to the stage and runs approximately 2 hours 40 minutes including one intermission. Click here for more information and for tickets.

It may seem like a small detail, but a dazzling chandelier plays a pivotal role in Andrew Lloyd Webber’s The Phantom of the Opera. It opens the show in its sheer majesty and the Phantom is actually found hiding in the glittering and monstrous powerhouse of a special effect at one point during the Broadway production. In fact, it is what fascinates the audience at the beginning of the musical in glorious rhythm with the thunderous and foreboding sound of a pipe organ blaring in the distance and what later crashes to makes the cast run in terror.
As a big Phantom of the Opera fan, I was relieved that aside from similar core story elements taken from Leroux’s famous novel, Yeston and Kopil’s Phantom is no imitation nor is it attempting to deliver Andrew Lloyd Webber’s organ-fueled intensity and spectacle. It stands separately as its own creation composed in Maury’s Yeston galloping and occasionally peppy waltzing rhythms. Yeston and Kopil’s Phantom boasts changes in tone and dives further into character development and back story to deliver a tale light on cynical gothic intensity, but dare I say, contains elements of optimism and humor during a dark time. Instead of a glittering chandelier, an extended symbolic bridge reaches far into the dark to deliver greater meaning later.

Yeston and Kopit’s Phantom features ornate and multicolor costumes with splendid Parisian-inspired flair in feathers, frills, top hats and tuxedos by costumers Martha Clarke and Morgan Andersen, the cast boasts sterling vocals, its emotive and haunting lighting blends with an immersive Parisian-inspired set by scenic and set designer Jack Mehler.
This version boasts some familiar and impressive special effects including a spinning pipe organ and a mystical underground lake. Mehler’s old fashioned opera lights, flickering vintage lampposts, rustic lanterns, and a candelabra lit lair glows orange on a misty lake which bring this somewhat opera within an opera to life.

Set at the turn of the century in France, Phantom focuses on a mysterious presence that haunts the famous Palais Garnier Opera House in Paris, France and was recently sold. New opera house co-owners Alex Syiek as Alain Cholet and Victoria Huston-Elem as La Carlotta make a distinguished and obnoxious pair extravagantly dressed and luxuriating in their riches.

Spoiled, demanding and vindictive with a snide smile, Victoria Huston-Elem is quite the spiteful presence as La Carlotta delivering a vehement This Place is Mine. Carlotta prances around the stage in signature diva fashion, bold and comical as she shouts her demands. Carlotta’s sophisticated gowns become more extravagant as the musical progresses and the cast hits its stylish stride for the pivotal number Bistro.

Webber’s Christine is somewhat of a mystery in her motivations, but Madison Claire Parks portrays a wide-eyed Christine, hailing from a small town in Oklahoma and dazzled by Paris. She remains naïve and innocent but with a sunnier disposition right down to her long blond waves.

Parks as Christine leads an effervescent Melody de Paris, longs for the opera stage, and illustrates her love for music in a beautiful duet with Sean Seamus Thomas in Home with a painfully lonely Phantom. Parks also wows in a stirring rendition of My True Love.

With a sense of humor more mainstream than caustic, Thomas as Phantom is more mysterious tortured soul than threat, though his deep and resounding vocals are still menacing offstage. He also does not work alone, but with a band of lost souls that do his bidding.

Thomas and Parks are a complex and charismatic pair while Christian Probst is well suited for the daring and charming Count Phillipe de Chandon. Parks and Probst perform a sweet rendition of Who Could Have Ever Dreamed Up You? Gregory North as Gerard Carriere is discerning and even tempered managing the opera house while navigating the Phantom’s escalating chaos for unexpected and surprising reasons.
North Shore Music Theatre continues Yeston and Kopil’s Phantom live and in person at North Shore Music Theatre in Beverly, Massachusetts through Sunday, November 1. Click here for more information and for tickets.






















































