REVIEW: ‘Mean Girls The Musical’ kind of makes fetch happen
As is the custom in this Mean Girls girl world, it was Wednesday and I work pink…fuchsia to be exact.
As a big fan of the 2004 hit film Mean Girls featuring Lindsey Lohan and Rachel McAdams, I couldn’t wait to revisit the famous catch phrases which became part of the pop culture landscape in this musical adaptation and it did not disappoint. While some of them are straight out of the 2004 film, other phrases are delivered slightly differently.
Mean Girls the Musical is mostly faithful to the 2004 film with some exceptions with some story elements expanded, enhanced or changed. Seeing the musical is a new experience.
With nimble direction and sharp choreography by Casey Nicholaw, Mean Girls the Musical continues live and in person at Emerson Colonial Theatre in Boston, Massachusetts through Sunday, May 4 before it continues on its national tour. This production is two hours and 30 minutes including one intermission. Click here for more information and for tickets.
Since the release of the 2004 film, Mean Girls the Musical ran on Broadway from 2018 through 2020 before the commercial success of the 2024 musical film starring Angourie Rice as Cady and Broadway’s Reneé Rapp as Regina.
Having never witnessed either the Broadway musical or the 2024 musical film, it was exciting to see this story unfold in a different genre from an updated perspective acknowledging the widespread use of social media. In 2004, North Shore High School student wrote in an actual Burn Book. It was a wild thought to consider how that might be imagined online, but fortunately, The Burn Book has not changed. Cells phones, social media and autocorrect are integrated into the musical’s enhanced plot.
From shimmering mirror reflections to vibrant and detailed backdrops, scenic designer Scott Pask’s rolling set unfolds at a thrillingly agile pace as montages of classrooms transform in simultaneous desk twirls. Kenneth Posner’s animated lighting can largely be considered its own character enhancing the musical’s quick pace through unique and changing patterns overhead in time to John Clancy’s upbeat orchestrations while at times lending to the humor in key scenes.
While some aspects of the musical do not quite live up to the 2004 film, other aspects are done better. This cautionary tale, introduced by Joshua Morrisey as Damian and Alexys Morera as Janis, begins with Katie Yaomens as adorably quirky, awkward and anxious new student Cady who has moved to Illinois from Kenya after being homeschooled her entire life. Boasting soaring vocals and expanding on Cady’s fearless and adventurous Kenyan spirit in the enchanting song, It Roars, Yaomens brings naiveté and earnestness with a certain charisma as Cady that you can’t help but root for her success. Yaomens further glows with optimism alongside José Raúl as Aaron Samuels in the number, Stupid with Love. However, Cady learns that high school is much more complicated than she could have imagined.
Yaomens shares some compelling scenes with Morrisey and Morera as they open Cady’s eyes to an entirely unfamiliar new way of life – high school. This trio builds amiable and playful camaraderie as the show progresses. Joshua Morrisey turns on the charm portraying theatrical Damian. From excellent tap dancing to show choirs to harmonious backup vocals to dance breaks, Morrisey is exuberant delivering funny and sage advice about impulsiveness we can all learn from in the insightful number, Stop and the value of finding your place in Where do you Belong with Alexys Morera as Janis and Yeomans as Cady. In fish net stockings, rhinestone denim shorts and bleached hair, Morera portrays an edgier Janis with finesse for Apex Predator and in the revealing number, I’d Rather Be Me.
Kristen Amanda Smith’s excitable and fast talking Gretchen is a bit too much at once and would benefit slowing down a bit, but Smith delivers some fabulous vocals, especially for the empathetic number, What’s Wrong with Me, diving into Gretchen’s insecurities and expanding on her character. Geekier and more energized, Kabir Gandhi’s iteration of Kevin G lacks the suave and smooth demeanor from the 2004 film which is missed. MaryRose Brendal is hilarious as dimwitted but not to be underestimated Karen and shines in the Halloween-inspired number, Sexy.
What made Rachel McAdams as Queen Bee Regina so appealing are those little glimpses of insecurity and weakness under that plastic facade. Maya Petropolos as Regina has real Valley girl bite, arrogance, and a deranged power over others demonstrated in a commanding rendition of My Name is Regina George, but that vulnerability is never truly explored.
It was genius to triple cast Kristen Seggio as frank and quirky Ms. Norbury, zoologist Mrs. Heron and “cool mom” Mrs. George. Seggio is so talented at portraying each distinctive character, it was difficult to believe they were depicted by the same person. Seggio portrays Ms. Norbury a bit quirkier while blending a similar nonchalant frankness that Tina Fey is famous for. Dialing down “cool mom” Mrs. George was a real benefit to the character while still cradling her signature large margarita peppered with umbrellas. Mean Girls the Musical expands on Mrs. George’s character during the sympathetic number, What’s Wrong With Me, bringing new dimension to this amusing character.
The students form a collective army of Regina’s minions and followers on the path to popularity which is reflected in Casey Nicholaw’s sharp choreography. Whether dancing while swinging bright red lunch trays for the captivating number, Where do You Belong, as jungle creatures gathering around the watering hole, but in this case, a fountain at the mall or as partiers in Whose House is This, Nicholaw’s lively chorography reflects the students’ hive mind mentality with each scene. Edgy and creative, costumer Gregg Barnes boasts an extraordinary array of innovative ensembles from sexy to shimmering to edgy to imaginative costumes which include transformers and sexy corn.
It was a lot of fun to see Mean Girls as an engaging musical and witness new elements in this lighthearted story while it also provides additional lessons surviving ‘girl world.’ In today’s world, we can all use a few more pointers.
Mean Girls the Musical continues live and in person at Emerson Colonial Theatre in Boston, Massachusetts through Sunday, May 4 before it continues on its national tour. Click here for more information and for tickets.
