REVIEW: The title is everything and more! Catch American Repertory Theater’s ‘Two Strangers (Carry a Cake across New York)’
Two people with seemingly nothing in common, one wedding cake, and several pieces of luggage lead to a string of possibilities in this delightful spin on a romantic comedy.
I will admit, I didn’t want it to end.
Imaginatively directed and choreographed by Tim Jackson, American Repertory Theater (A.R.T.) presents Jim Barne and Kit Buchan’s romantic musical comedy, Two Strangers (Carry a Cake across New York) live and in person at the Loeb Drama Center in Cambridge, Massachusetts extended through Sunday, July 13. This fabulous production runs two hours and 10 minutes including one intermission. Click here for more information and for tickets.

On December 2, two strangers meet at a New York City airport unaware that their futures are connected. That is until Sam Tutty as naïve and perpetually optimistic Brit Dougal discovers that Christiani Pitts as cynical New Yorker Robin is Dougal’s ride from the airport. How they become connected to an expensive wedding cake is where the plot thickens.
Scenic and costume designer Soutra Gilmour cleverly makes innovative use of a pile of strategically placed luggage on a conveyer belt which multitasks as a coffee shop, hotel room, a dance club packed with a string of shimmering disco balls, and several other surprises that will not be revealed here. The rotating conveyer belt is a brilliant addition to the production that translates into multiple uses in various settings. Along with Music Director Jeffrey Campos working in conjunction with Sound Designer Tony Gayle and Cody Spencer, lighting designer Jack Knowles brings it all to life with the playful, flourishing and multicolored neon brilliance of Times Square to each of the onstage band’s rhythmic beat. It is one of the most inventive sets I have seen in a long time.

Sam Tutty evokes an innate charisma as Dougal, a guileless and irresistible British charmer who is visiting New York City for a wedding. Tutty’s Dougal is a movie loving, excitable, sincere, rose colored glasses, speak out of turn and puppy dog kind of charming that if Dougal does not win the girl, he will surely win over the audience. Dougal is only in New York for 48 hours to see his absentee dad get married and it is back to England. With a characteristic vibrato, Tutty expresses Dougal’s dreamy excitement for adventure in a duet with Pitts in New York and hopeful optimism in a reflective rendition of Dad.
Christiani Pitts is also terrific as cynical New Yorker Robin who is holding back a secret. While Dougal seems to love life and charges at its possibilities with fun loving enthusiasm, Robin approaches life financially-hanging-on-by-a-thread hampered by a complicated family life struggling to make ends meet in more ways than one. Robin sees the world just as it is and is more concerned about surviving it than taking it all in as exemplified in Pitts’s solo rendition of What’ll it Be.

What these two do have in common is they are lost and trying to find their place in the world and within their family. They also have a lot more to learn about each other than they realize as demonstrated in their contemplative duet Be Happy.
If you think you know how this romantic comedy musical will turn out, Two Strangers holds plenty of surprises up its sleeve and brings a refreshing new take to the romcom. Leaving behind any shallow or empty plotlines that some romantic comedies are culpable, Two Strangers deliver a self aware and satirical approach to these scenarios through dialogue and song. It is a wink to past romantic comedies while also veering into new territory offering authentically exhilarating and stirring moments.

Much of that is due to the crackling chemistry between Christiani Pitts and Sam Tutty who banter, tease, joke, disagree and reflect on the their individual lives and their views on the future. Their irresistible affinity towards each other is endlessly entertaining and creates beautiful harmony in several duets, but especially for their humorous (and a little naughty) duet, On the App.
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake across New York) boasts catchy and unique pop-infused melodies that these leads seem to master effortlessly with charm, style and finesse. Pitts lends fluttering vocals and a mix of anxiousness and rising hopefulness to the powerful ballad This Year. Pitts also masters the a cappella and vocal gymnastics of the hysterical and hilarious number, The Hangover alongside Tutty.

Amusing, original, feel good and inventive, make time to witness how this heartfelt story unfolds! Two Strangers (Carry a Cake across New York) stands as one of my favorite productions this year.
American Repertory Theater (A.R.T.) presents Jim Barne and Kit Buchan’s romantic musical comedy, Two Strangers (Carry a Cake across New York) live and in person at the Loeb Drama Center in Cambridge, Massachusetts extended through Sunday, July 13. Click here for more information and for tickets.













































